LINUXTALKS.CO

История изменений

Исправление crypt, (текущая версия) :

ну и дурак

corrupts the LV, every time.

I'm having an issue with my LV's becoming corrupted very easily and often. Wondering if anyone else is experiencing this issue while using Arch. Just want to scratch some things off the list such as kernel 5.0 and the newest lvm2.

Further Details:

smartctl long test passed.

no errors in logs outside of what is caused by the corruption and have been resolved

Both the EXT4 and NTFS LV's have experienced continuous corruption

The corruption is only to content, not to the structure of the LVM in any way.

The drive is a 1TB spinning rust

There's no reported issues in LVM's git.

Corruption only happens during a hard power off of either my PC or one of my VM's. File system doesn't matter, happens to all of them, ext4, ntfs, etc

The questions are,

Is LVM this fragile for anyone else lately?

Is there possibly a setting or a piece of software I should be using to increase reliability?

As a note, yes, I am aware you shouldn't hard power off due to the risk of data loss and corruption. However it has become FAR worse and very often to the point of being every time with LVM for me.

UPDATE: Clarification. It's not just the host, it's the VM's as well. Hard powering off,

"virsh destroy GUEST"

corrupts the LV, every time. 

https://www.reddit.com/r/archlinux/comments/bm2cnw/lvm_easily_corrupted/

Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7.6+ is exposed to corruption where LVM might cause data corruption in the first 128kB of the LVM volume

Исправление crypt, :

ну и дурак

corrupts the LV, every time.

I'm having an issue with my LV's becoming corrupted very easily and often. Wondering if anyone else is experiencing this issue while using Arch. Just want to scratch some things off the list such as kernel 5.0 and the newest lvm2.

Further Details:

smartctl long test passed.

no errors in logs outside of what is caused by the corruption and have been resolved

Both the EXT4 and NTFS LV's have experienced continuous corruption

The corruption is only to content, not to the structure of the LVM in any way.

The drive is a 1TB spinning rust

There's no reported issues in LVM's git.

Corruption only happens during a hard power off of either my PC or one of my VM's. File system doesn't matter, happens to all of them, ext4, ntfs, etc

The questions are,

Is LVM this fragile for anyone else lately?

Is there possibly a setting or a piece of software I should be using to increase reliability?

As a note, yes, I am aware you shouldn't hard power off due to the risk of data loss and corruption. However it has become FAR worse and very often to the point of being every time with LVM for me.

UPDATE: Clarification. It's not just the host, it's the VM's as well. Hard powering off,

"virsh destroy GUEST"

corrupts the LV, every time. 

https://www.reddit.com/r/archlinux/comments/bm2cnw/lvm_easily_corrupted/

Исходная версия crypt, :

ну и дурак

I'm having an issue with my LV's becoming corrupted very easily and often. Wondering if anyone else is experiencing this issue while using Arch. Just want to scratch some things off the list such as kernel 5.0 and the newest lvm2.

Further Details:

smartctl long test passed.

no errors in logs outside of what is caused by the corruption and have been resolved

Both the EXT4 and NTFS LV's have experienced continuous corruption

The corruption is only to content, not to the structure of the LVM in any way.

The drive is a 1TB spinning rust

There's no reported issues in LVM's git.

Corruption only happens during a hard power off of either my PC or one of my VM's. File system doesn't matter, happens to all of them, ext4, ntfs, etc

The questions are,

Is LVM this fragile for anyone else lately?

Is there possibly a setting or a piece of software I should be using to increase reliability?

As a note, yes, I am aware you shouldn't hard power off due to the risk of data loss and corruption. However it has become FAR worse and very often to the point of being every time with LVM for me.

UPDATE: Clarification. It's not just the host, it's the VM's as well. Hard powering off,

"virsh destroy GUEST"

corrupts the LV, every time.